ACTIVITY: Chronic Risk Factors (Cycle 7)

Using the Assessment of Intimate Partner’s Homicide Risk handout, read the full scenario and answer the following questions:
SCENARIO: Elisapee is Granted Her Divorce
Background
The machinery of justice proceeded even with Peter in jail. The judge approved the divorce petition, and the final child support and custody arrangements. Elisapee was also awarded spousal support in the ruling. It didn’t seem to matter now though, since Peter was incarcerated and no money was flowing. The social worker arranged bi-weekly phone calls for Simeonie to speak with his father, but those rarely happened. Out of sight seemed to be out of mind for her son, and he was pretty embarrassed over his dad’s actions, so Peter felt further alienated. Only his mother reached out to him.
Peter was served the divorce decree while in jail, which impacted his already hardened mindset. While he was keeping busy in jail by attending prosocial programming, meeting with the Chaplain, going to Sunday service, reading books and exercising, he had a lot of time to think about Elisapee. His preoccupation became obsessive and believed that since what he and Elisapee mutually called the “dark period” was behind them, they could start fresh when he was released. They had both grown up a lot; they weren’t kids anymore, but he believed she still loved him and he was her man. To him the divorce certificate was just a piece of paper. They were soulmates and he would never let her go.
During Peter’s incarceration, Elisapee met a nice man, David, and they started dating. He was an instructor at her college, in a completely different program than hers, and they hit it off. He was from Victoria, British Columbia originally, but came to the college on a two-year contract. He had done other amazing teaching gigs before coming to the community. He taught English in Korea after graduating university; did his teacher’s college degree in England; worked with disabled youth in the United States at a private college, and was doing his Masters in Education part time, just “for fun”. So worldly, so smart and funny. She was falling for him: hard. She was ready to move on from the “dark period” and find love again.
Elisapee would often invite David over for supper, and David couldn’t resist a good home cooked meal and the distraction of her baked goods and her company. They started watching Netflix shows together, and had their own inside jokes. Even Simeonie enjoyed having David around, to play video games on the second controller, and it made Simeonie feel at peace knowing that his mom was happy. Elisapee and David were serious, and the with divorce finalized, they talked about settling down together. Elisapee was done her courses, finishing her practicum at the Health Centre, and would be officially graduating in June with her Registered Nurse credentials. Simeonie was finishing middle school and getting ready for high school. David’s contract was finished at the end of May and was open to new travels and new possibilities. Together, the three of them talked about the future, and what was next for them.
Simeonie thought about staying in the community, with his dad coming home in the next month. However, so much time had passed and his perception of his dad had changed after learning about what his dad did to his mom. He was so young, he didn’t remember much, but he loved his mom and was proud of her. With David in the picture now, and the possibility of moving, he was open to getting out of the small town and starting high school somewhere new, and making new friends. He was old enough to make his own choice as to who he wanted to live with, but he knew his dad and his grandparents would want him to stay here.
Crisis Phase / Forms of Violence
During a shift at the Health Centre, Elisapee received a call from Correctional Services Canada, advising her that Peter was scheduled for release from custody in two weeks time. He had completed his sentence, and would be flown back to the community. He would have some conditions and would have to report to his probation officer, but the details she didn’t really listen to. As far as she was concerned, he did his time, and it was time to move forward in her life. She spent so many years of wasted time, energy and healing from that man, she just wanted to close the chapter and move on.
She and David and Simeonie agreed that after the school graduations, that they would leave on July 1st, Canada Day, and make a fresh new start in Victoria, British Columbia. They would fly to Montreal, where David bought a brand new SUV, and they would make the cross country tour over 2 months, camping, exploring and making new memories. It was only two months away, and every night the trio would map out the road trip and find interesting places and landmarks they wanted to see, and the camp sites or motels they would stay at.
Elisapee and David were already planning to get married in the fall with a simple civil ceremony and take a weekend away together to Tofino. Elisapee already had a job lined up at Victoria Public Health Unit after the summer, and David had his name in for teaching contracts. Simeonie was interested in joining the marine cadets and wanted to pursue football at high school: activities that didn’t exist here at home.
Elisapee’s sister-in-law was so happy for her and Simeonie, but Peter’s family were not altogether happy that she was relocating and taking Simeonie away from his community, family and father, particularly all the way on the other side of Canada.
When Peter arrived back home, he got a hero’s welcome from his parents and buddies. Simeonie was invited to the party, and was glad to see his dad, but it was awkward. So much time had passed, and he felt somewhat conflicted about the bond he now had with David, who for all intents and purposes was his stepfather. Peter didn’t waste any time and started probing Simeonie for details about Elisapee’s new boyfriend. Simeonie thought his dad seemed surprisingly fine about his mom dating David, but didn’t realize that in his excitement about sharing the plans they had to drive cross country, move to British Columbia, his mom’s engagement and new plans, he was fueling a powder cake of jealousy and anger.
Within days of arriving back home, Peter was texting Elisapee and accusing her of infidelity with her new relationship, since she was clearly dating him while they were still married. While he was set to start back at work the following week, she caught him driving around the Health Centre, parking in front of the building, and just staring at her for several minutes before driving away. He did that every day for the next few days to make a point that he was home.
Learning that David was a teacher at the college, Peter made an anonymous report to the Department of Youth Protection, claiming that there were suspicions of David making sexual advances to Simeonie, and possibly other boys in the community. This, of course, became a professional nightmare for David, with investigations into not just his current teaching post and activities, but with inquiries into past jobs and placements. Finally, Peter consulted with his lawyer and sent Elisapee official notice that under the terms of their Joint Custody agreement, she required his approval to relocate Simeonie outside of the community and province for any travel, including relocation for work or personal reasons. Elisapee was furious and knew Peter was behind the false allegations and trying to get back at her for moving on.
In retaliation, she contacted her lawyer as well, citing Peter’s stalking her at work, intimidation and harassment, and trying to strong arm her under the terms of the Joint Custody conditions. The lawyer advised Elisapee to report his harassing behaviour to the police, because any breach of conditions or criminal activity could trigger his return to jail. The lawyer immediately drafted a Motion to Change the Child Custody order, given Peter’s actions. Elisapee thought to herself, how could she have been so stupid to think that Peter could let her go and give her an ounce of respect. Give an inch, and he’ll take a mile every time. Now she was going for the jugular.
During the period of Peter’s incarceration, he had not paid any money to Elisapee of the court ordered in child support for Simeonie, spousal support and financial remedies ordered from the IVAC financial compensation. Her lawyer filed emergency motions on financial matters for all outstanding arrears and for garnishment of wages, liens on his vehicles and any property, etc. There was also an emergency order for Sole Custody and peace bond to restrict physical access and any communications with Simeonie, David and Elisapee, given Peter’s threats and behaviour.
Elisapee showed up to Peter’s workplace first thing Monday morning, since she knew when his team would be having their tailgate meeting, and screamed at him. “If you think you can waltz back into town and intimidate and lie about my fiancée, use our kid for information, stalk me at work and stop me from getting on with my life, then you’ve got another thing coming. I’m going to bury you financially: you haven’t paid a dime in court ordered support. I’m not your punching bag anymore, and you can take that smug f&*$g smile off your face. Everybody knows who you are, especially God. Your day is coming.”.
Peter was humiliated in front of his buddies, his peers, and the human resources manager and supervisor called him into the office to talk. Clearly these were serious allegations made of him, and they needed to know the situation and how to support him moving forward.
Remission/Remorse/Reconciliation Phase
While Peter’s parents supported him in principle and didn’t want to see Simeonie leave the community, they saw the lengths that Peter would go to hurt Elisapee. Peter was being cruel to her and her new partner, and it was not healthy for Simeonie to be experiencing the tension and stress.
Peter texted Elisapee that he was sorry, but on the advice of her lawyer and David, she blocked him. Any communications were through the lawyer, and that costed money. Peter relayed messages through Simeonie, but he didn’t pass them along. Peter said that he just reacted to Elisapee moving on, but his family saw that he really wasn’t taking accountability for his actions. It was clear that he was not truly repentant before God for his sins, but they encouraged his to stay close to his faith and pray. They were truly at a loss on how to support him.
Calm/Honeymoon
With the help of his human resources manager at work regarding the amounts to be garnished bi-weekly from his wages, and with the help of his bank manager to liquidate his RRSP and selling his snow machine, Peter got his personal affairs managed. He was being good to make all of his meetings with his probation officer and getting back into a work routine.
Tension Building
The date was set to hear the Motion to change the child custody order. Given the volatility of the marriage, the serious violence and recent actions by Peter, the judge granted Elisapee sole custody and permission to take Simeonie out of the province for work relocation. As the custodial parent, Elisapee did not need Peter’s permission for anything related to Simeonie, and they were free to leave the community.
Peter was emotionally distraught, as were his parents. When leaving the courthouse, Peter said that he may as well just kill himself. He has nothing else to live for now since she’s taken my money, my son and my pride.

