ACTIVITY – Chronic Risk Factors (Cycle 1)

Using the Assessment of Intimate Partner’s Homicide Risk handout, read the full scenario and answer the following questions:
SCENARIO: The Birth of their First Child
Background
Peter started using more overt violence because the increased commitment made it more difficult for Elisapee to break off the relationship. He was slowly gaining power in the relationship – slowly pushing Elisapee’s boundaries and putting her in a state of inner imbalance. Peter was beginning to gain power over the relationship.
Crisis Phase / Forms of Violence
On April 5th, their first child Simeonie was born. Peter resented the baby getting all of Elisapee’s attention day and night, as a newborn requires. As Elisapee stood up and put the baby in the crib after the last evening feeding, Peter arrived at the bedroom door and blocked her from leaving the room. He had been drinking. He grabbed her wrists and threw her to the ground. Elisapee fought back and tried to get up, he was so strong. He kicked her in the belly, hard. Elisapee tried to reason with him, asking what she did wrong, sobbing and blocking her stomach. He straddled her, choked her, then left the house for the rest of the night.
Remission/Remorse/Reconciliation Phase
Elisapee was in shock. She couldn’t believe what he did. She picked up the baby and went immediately to the health centre. The stitches from her C-section had been opened from the kick. The nurse cleaned and stitched her up and took notes of the wounds. The nurse noted the clear signs of petechiae: the markings on Elisapee’s neck, eyes, cheeks, roof of her mouth indicating at least 30 sustained seconds of manual strangulation. She asked Elisapee how she got these injuries, and asked if she would like to talk to the police. She has nowhere to go. No family, friends or resources to leave. The nurse took detailed notes and provided contact information for the local shelter, social worker and police, and offered to reach out on her behalf, if Elisapee provided authorization. Elisapee said she would think about it. She was in a fog and just needed time to think.
Peter came home at lunch the next day after his morning shift at work. He appeared normal, as though nothing happened the night before. Elisapee was still in shock. Peter said he felt bad – drank too much and got out of hand. Said it would never happen again. Elisapee said she wants Peter to go see the Church leader for guidance. He apologized and promised to improve, and said that maybe she should wear some makeup on the marks or a turtleneck if she’s going out.
He stroked her hair, gave her gentle caresses and protective hug and whispered that he loves her. Would never do it again. Wanted to make love to show her his love for her.
Elisapee said that they need help to communicate better and be more respectful toward each other. Perhaps she had been too consumed with the baby and was ignoring Peter. Peter said that her perception was right – it was all about communication and spending time together as a couple, and he didn’t realize how tired he was with the new baby and added responsibilities. He said she could start communicating with him in the bedroom. He pulled out his bible to a tab he marked in 1 Corinthians 7:2–5: “Each man should have sexual relations with his own wife, and each woman with her own husband. The husband should fulfill his marital duty to his wife, and likewise the wife to her husband”, and winked to her, as he led her to the bedroom. Elisapee was never fully at peace again, knowing that Peter had the ability to be violent like that with her. But she rationalized that she married him for better or worse, and in the eyes of God, he was the man of the house and a good provider, so what else could she want. She would just have to be a better wife.
Calm/Honeymoon
For the next eight months, Peter and Elisapee’s relationship was going well. Peter attended church every Sunday with Elisapee and the baby, and his family loved spending time with them and took the new baby occasionally so the young couple could spend time together. Peter was not going out as much with his friends, or drinking, and he spent more time with his father and hunting group to keep the freezers full of country food. Elisapee was feeling settled, keeping the house clean, baby fed, and felt like she was getting in her groove. Peter even said that he met with the Anglican priest to talk about his anger issues, and Elisapee believed him, thinking he really did want to address his issues. She expressed that once Simeonie was potty trained, that she would get him into daycare a few days a week so she could return to her studies for her career.
Tension-Building
Once the toddler was ready for daycare, Elisapee returned to school taking two courses. Peter started acting erratically again, criticizing her choice to go back to school. He blamed her for not having enough time for them as a couple; that Simeonie is missing his mother, and that she is selfish by wanting to do things for herself.
He enlists his parents in pressuring her to make a choice for her family and quit school, just for now. His family, especially his mother, reinforced her responsibility as a woman is to her husband, child, and household, and that her needs were being selfish. She need to obey Peter’s authority and do as he says, as the head of the family.
Over a period of three months, Peter creates a climate of tension. He withdrew his affection, and they never made love anymore. He started drinking again every night, and criticized her studies. would yell any time the baby cried and told her to keep the baby quiet “or else”.
On the night before an important mid-term exam, Elisapee made his favourite supper in an attempt to show him she can do it all: be a dutiful loving wife, good mother, be attentive and put the family first. In a rage, he threw his plate of supper against the wall and threatened her that if she doesn’t quit school, then he will find someone else who is not selfish. Elisapee tried to reason with him, asking where is this coming from? She was always clear with him that her dream was to be a professional nurse and have a career, and in the beginning he said that he loved that about her and would always support her in anything she wanted to achieve.
In response, Elisapee withdrew, feeling dejected and lost. Her lifelong dream of becoming a nurse was being directly threatened again; her little family was living in a house of yelling and fear; she was in a crisis of faith and feeling emotionally and physically alone. She doesn’t feel that she is doing anything wrong, but she feels she must not be measuring up.

